Leading Counsel for the Appellant may take the facts of the case as read in opening the case, so it is not advisable to take up time repeating them. An Overview of Opening Statements. Mooting is a skill that can be learned. crime / tort / property / contract / employment law. Mooting is competitive mock trial competition that is carried out at an appellate court. Mooting Script for Leading Appellant GROUND 1 - REVOCATION OF ENTRY PERMIT IS NOT VALID Leading Appellant: May it please Your Lordship, my name is Miss Amera Mohd Yusof and I appear as senior counsel, representing the appellant. By Tanishka Sahajwalla Mooting could be a daunting exercise for many, but once mastered, it can be an addiction. My learned friend Miss Eisah Radiah Ramli will be junior council for . The Supreme Court: from October 2009, the Supreme Court replaced the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords as the highest court in the United Kingdom. By Tanishka Sahajwalla Mooting could be a daunting exercise for many, but once mastered, it can be an addiction. "Legal Drafting Rules - Tips", by Aman Hingorani 51 14. In the appellant's case, by arresting the appellant, they are prevented from planning further protests, hence limiting the exercise of their rights under article 10's freedom of . " The biggest difference between moot court and mock trial is the difference . Junior for the Appellant. sponsored and hosted by Davies, Ward, Phillips & Vineberg LLP, students participating in this competition debate issues of corporate and securities law. 2. Junior for the Respondent. 3.12 Don't . Mooting is a skill that helps you enhance your knowledge of the law while polishing your presentation and speaking skills. Appellant's Senior Counsel only will stand and say How would you explain this case to a friend over a beer? Taking part in the Moot will certainly help you improve your written and oral communication skills. Moot Court Problem - 6 50 13. Mock trial involves a whole trial. Party Names Applicant - The party that files a civil or criminal application is referred to as an Applicant. In most countries, the phrase "moot court" may be shortened to simply "moot" or "mooting". Say that you "adopt the submissions of your Learned Junior". . Dr Marston now appeals to the Court of Appeal on the ground that both rulings were erroneous, and that his conviction is accordingly . As a Junior appellant I have to answer question 2 on the moot: 2. For example, where a court considers a meaning to be given to particular legal words in a statute (i.e. PDF 526kB These submissions were prepared by two teams that competed in the 2012 Oxford IP Moot. . . For example, you should look at the: statements of case - civil cases; charge sheet and indictment - criminal cases; threshold document and composite schedule of allegations - family cases; You may identify weaknesses with your client's case. The following student resources are available to accompany this book: Practical exercises - Download the documents with guidance for the activities referenced throughout the text; Answers to self-test questions - The answers are provided along with a commentary to help understand how and why the correct answer was reached; Glossary - A useful one-stop reference point for all the keywords and . That Dr Marston's belief that the life-support system would give Baby E a greater chance of. The winner of the Mori Issues moot is the recipient of the Gina Rudland Prize. conclusion. They represent a party, prepare a case for trial and try the case before judges, who are usually law professors, and even from judiciary. The purpose of making these submissions available is to give prospective teams an indication of the style and tone that should be adopted when drafting submissions. law passed by the government), this involves the parties in the moot to assist the court in providing a lawful interpretation of the legal words in question. Structure of a Moot In Senior Mooting there are four competitors per courtroom The two sides are Appellant or Respondent Each side will have a Junior and a Senior Seating You will argue different Grounds of appeal Structure of a Moot (Con't) Start with formal introductions Then appearances Generally, you are appealing an error of law, or fact, or both. In+thematter+of+SiphoSeakamela&and&WhiteySwart&vs.+SGB of&Kruger&High&School,&in+theConstitutional&Court&of&South& Africa . Be prepared: Identify relevant issues in the case scenario; Reading from books, cases etc. How to Moot. Defendan] THE RESPONDENT'S WRITTEN SUBMISSION A. A moot is a legal debate in a courtroom setting usually, but not exclusively involving a case taken on appeal. . It is important to prepare, below is an outline of how to prepare. The 3rd Appellant gave a statement from the dock where the learned judge rejected his defence. Short, pithy phrases or sentences may, however, be read from a note - e.g. Mooting is competitive mock trial competition. Direct Examination. Conclude with a brief summary of the totality of your team's submissions and state what you seek from the Judge eg. Appellate advocacy does not involve witnesses, or pieces of evidence (which occurs at the trial level). Tuesday 6 February 2018, 6.00 - 8.00pm: Round 1 of the Leicester and Leicestershire mooting competition 2017/2018. Injury Victim (outline for witness) Injury Victim #2 . Pay attention to the key documents. On the other hand, if the Mooter has approximately one minute remaining then the Mooter would likely deliver the longer conclusion. My Lady, as you know, the appellant argues that the sentence given to the appellant was disproportionate as it is inconsistent with their convention rights. Mooting is competitive mock trial competition that is carried out at an appellate court. This moot provides 16 students an opportunity to moot on a topic in the area of criminal or constitutional law. Mooting Script for Leading Appellant GROUND 1 - REVOCATION OF ENTRY PERMIT IS NOT VALID Leading Appellant: May it please Your Lordship, my name is Miss Amera Mohd Yusof and I appear as senior counsel, representing the appellant. For example, if a Mooter is about to run out of time - possibly due to numerous inquiries from the panel of judges - then the Mooter would likely apply the shorter conclusion. A moot is a fictional legal case which usually centres around a simulated appellate court case. There are no juries or witnesses as the moot is in the appeal courts (usually the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court) and so the facts of the case are already established. In a moot two teams of counsel attempt to persuade a judge of the strength of their case by reference to legal authority. Team Preparation. Here is a list of nine terminologies that you must know if you are a novice mooter. In Mohd Nazri Bin Omar & Ors. : John Snape, Gary Watt. Mr Chan candidly revealed that he was constantly scolded by Professor Beckman for speaking too fast. Mock trial involves a whole trial. Tuesday 6 March 2018, 6.00 - 8.00pm: (see: 10 Proven Ways To Overcome Nervousness And Become A Better Public Speaker.) Mooters examine errors of law and submit arguments as to what the correct finding should be. A moot is a mock appeal whereby 2 teams put forward a legal argument in front of a judge or panel of judges. progression of the facts. Written by lecturers with many years' experience of supporting students and judging at internal and national mooting competitions, you can be sure that this book contains everything you . It would be a good idea to script, bolden, or colour the different types of pointers. It is one of the best ways to enhance your legal skills. Moot court involves simulated proceedings before an appellate court, arbitral tribunal, or international dispute resolution body.These are different from mock trials that involve simulated jury trials or bench trials.Moot court does not involve actual testimony by witnesses, cross-examination, or the presentation of evidence, but is focused solely on the application of the law to a common set . My learned friend Miss Eisah Radiah Ramli will be junior council for . In doing so, it explains what international mooting is, the research methodology involved and the most useful resources available for its preparation. Mooting is a skill that helps you enhance your knowledge of the law while polishing your presentation and speaking skills. 6. . Research assistance, subject guides and useful library resources for first year law students, compiled by the Faculty of Law librarians Legal skills and research tips . Mooting also revealed one of Mr Chan's struggles - controlling the speed of his speech. The team legal memo must consist of the following: A cover page that includes the name of the court to which the matter is being appealed, the title of proceedings, the title of the document (e.g. Judges are more likely to pick up counsel's line of argument and, hopefully, approve of the submissions. Many say that mooting is only for those who want to become a barrister, but this is a MISCONCEPTION! This is an example of what written submissions to the court could look like. Steven Nolan Moot Convenor The English-Speaking Union Dartmouth House, 37 Charles Street London W1J 5ED T . Mark Godfrey of the University of Glasgow will act as this year's National Adjudicator. Mooters are not interested in questions of evidence. Divide the team and assign tasks. held by Mathews, Dinsdale & Clarke LLP, students prepare both management and . e.g. Sample written submissions. It is usually possible to intertwine the relevant facts of your submissions within the skeleton itself. A Primer to Oral Argument For those yet unfamiliar with the in's and out's of moot court oral argument, the following should serve as a guide. Leader for the Appellant. Appellate Argument Demonstration Exercise - Narcotics Control Bureau . Viv Windsor (Respondent) Viv has just bought "The Village Shop" and, anxious to please the locals, decides to put an advertisement in the local paper stating that she will sell boxes of luxury chocolate shortbread at a discount price of 2.50, instead of the recommended retail price of 5.00. You should make sure that your submissions relate to the circumstances of your case. Whilst it is very important to practice beforehand, it is advisable to not prepare a script; if, however, you intend on preparing a script, it is paramount that you learn it, so that in the event you . the process of mooting to a certain extent can be characterised as a replication . An introduction to mooting and an opportunity to sign up to the 2017/2018 Leicestershire Schools and Colleges Mooting Competition. Mooting is done within an appellate court. v. PP5 the appellants were charged for an offence of drugs trafficking. Use the more recent mooting problems where possible. Even if you are new to mooting if you prepare well and understand the scenario, the law, have practiced your arguments in front of others repeatedly and understand your objective, or narrative of how Appellant's Legal . Would Your Ladyship find a brief summary of the facts of the instant case helpful? Many say that mooting is only for those who want to become a barrister, but this is a MISCONCEPTION! It is not to be confused with the mock trial. View: 466. Example of a mooting script mooting script may it please your ladyship, my name is and appear as the counsel, representing the respondent. A well-written submission, a logically built-up argument is easier for a judge to understand. This is an Appeal by the appellant/Defendant against the Judgment pronounced by the High Court of Alor Setar on 15.5.2011 in favour of the Respondent/Plaintiff in the Civil Suit No. These will differ depending on the type of case. It is one of the best ways to enhance your legal skills. mooting script respondent - sit at left of the room My Lord, if your Lordship pleases, May it pleases your lordship, I submit/contend that (X I feel/think, X I would like to submit) My Lord, I submit that In my respectful submission May I submit that/ May I put it to the court that I accept the point that , however, Mooting is perhaps the closest practical example that a law student gets to arbitration and court proceedings of the higher courts. v. Elizabeth Brown. Winners 2017: Reuben Hurliman, Sameer Mandhan and Liam Haughey . Decide on the preliminary stance in relation to . The first thing to do is to look carefully at the problem, try to summarise it, and work out what area, or areas, of law the problem deals with. The date on which the problem was added to MootingNet is given after the PDF link for more recently added problems. Moot Court Problem - 3 46 10. 25 7. ask for the present appeal/reclaiming motion to be dismissed. For more information on preparing submissions like this, see Your submissions . survival than Baby C was no defence to the charge. Return to top Mooting gives students the change to improve their public speaking and advocacy skills through participating in mock appeal cases and mock trials. Leader for the Respondent. Case Law and Legislation preparation. Moot Court Problem - 2 45 9. Mooters are not interested in questions of evidence. b. a script for a lecture to a class of first (or last) year law students; c. a professorial style commentary on the strengths and weaknesses of the case; d. an impassioned speech to constituents or to the House of Commons; e. an introductory warm-up to a group therapy discussion or TV chat show; f. the first draft of a Law Review article; g. Mooters are not interested in questions of evidence. Moot court is a co-curricular activity at many law schools. not a script; Counsel should not read prepared speeches. In a student moot the teams consist of two pairs of students representing appellant and respondent debating in a . These examples are illustrative only, and should not be regarded as prescriptive. What does Mooting involve? everyone stands. Participants take part in simulated court or arbitration proceedings, usually involving drafting memorials or memoranda and participating in oral argument. The 2016 Paralegal Cup Mooting Steering Committee (Committee) has assigned each team to write the legal memo as the Appellant. Used to promote social and economic policies and is mostly a forward planning type of law. INTRODUCTION 1. mooting script initial greeting1 judge knocks judge enters. 1 General Outline of a Moot Court Argument INTRO May it please the court, my name is _____ and I represent the Petitioner/Respondent __(name)___. Reading, as with other subjects, will enhance your knowledge of what is required. For further guidance, consult a member of the Moot Court Board and/or view a video recording of past Hardt Cup or Dean's Cup finals. Usually, the team who is best prepared will win. for the purpose of summarising the proposition which you are seeking to put forward. Mooters examine errors of law and submit arguments as to what the correct finding should be. EXAMPLE OF LEADING APPELLANT MOOTING'S SCRIPT. Preliminary Round Scoring Criteria Bundle and Skeleton Argument (5 points) You will be judged on how well you have prepared for the moot on paper. I was involved in the Mooting Society, which runs a large competition every year and brings in legal practitioners and judges from (for example) the Court of Session and the UK Supreme Court to judge the final of the competition. Moot court involves a single oral argument for each side, plus a rebuttal for the petitioner. if there is registrar say. for the Rosamund Smith Mooting Cup. Considering the fact that the memorials make up 50% of the total score, making a good memorial is actually critical. Key Requirements. However, when the judges throw you off from your pointers, do not panic. In addition to crafting a legal argument, mooters are Mooters examine errors of law and submit arguments as to what the correct finding should be. 1 Review. 1. The Mori Issues moot is open to all students in Parts III and IV in semester 2. An example of a type 3 question is detailed below at 1.2.1.4 and has been annotated to demonstrate the extent of the question asked. " The biggest difference between moot court and mock trial is the difference . Defendant's Opening Statement #1. Time limits. This moot provides students the opportunity to argue on points of law expressly concerning Mori issues. 2nd. If you need more help preparing your written submissions, get legal advice. . Moot court involves a single oral argument for each side, plus a rebuttal for the petitioner. Mooting is commonly considered to be a fun activity enjoyed by (at least) some students and members of academic staff. Moot Court Problem - 5 48 12. ne of the most significant findings of the 2006 survey for the Mooting for learning project was that 93% of responding institutions mooted in some form, confirming that it is an important part of law school life. You will then need to read all . It is usually best to work initially in a pair on the moot problem until you can identify the issues and split up the work fairly. How to Moot is essential reading for student mooters at all levels. Wrongful Death Survival Action (this is more of a detailed outline than a transcript) Answers to your questions on how to give a winning moot court opening statement. Reply to the arguments put by Senior for the Appellant/Reclaimer. An example of an in-text citation is as follows: 'First, a duty of care requires that the Respondent take reasonable care to avoid a foreseeable risk of injury to the class of persons to which the Appellant belongs: Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v Zaluzna (1987) 162 CLR 479, 488 (Mason, Wilson, Deane and Dawson JJ).' lOMoARcPSD|9305974 Mooting Script May it please Your Ladyship, my name is _____ and I appear as the counsel, representing the respondent.